When I first saw this book in the SMC library I was shocked. What do you all think? Is it approperiate? http://www.amazon.com/Beautiful-Mommy-Michael-Alexander-Salzhauer/dp/1601310323/ref=sr_1_7?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1240193805&sr=1-7
It's a book explaining to children what will happen when Mommy has plastic surgery. Although I know it is supposed to make children feel comfortable with what is happening, I worry that it promotes a unhealth body image to kids.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
WOW!!!! completely unexpected. I have to agree it is giving the wrong idea. I feel it is saying that if you dont like ur body in any way changing it is always the way. it gives the wrong idea that any imperfection is wrong. how is it promoting children feeling better with what is happening when they can't even feel comfortable with their own changes... idk.
ReplyDeleteit is very odd i think
This is ridiculous, but a great find for us to scathingly tear apart here on your blog and I wish in class, too.
ReplyDeleteCan I just highlight a few ridiculous lines from the product description:
"Through vivid illustrations and straightforward dialogue, My Beautiful Mommy explains a parent s physical transformation in a breezy, child-friendly manner from a young child s perspective. You and your child will follow along as Mommy goes through her plastic surgery experience and learn how the entire family pitches in to help Mommy achieve her beautiful results."
and a from a reviewer:
"When I recently decided to have a tummy tuck, my friend suggested that I buy this book to read with my 5 year old. I have to say, that was a great suggestion. It's a terrific book and I would recommend it to any mom planning cosmetic surgery."
Gosh there is just so much going on here and to consider. Looking solely at the first description, it was written with an eerie air of whimsy. This is not your ordinary fairy tale but then I am going to splinter her and think, which fairy tales are we talking about: purified Disney or the Brother Grimm? How does this have any correlation? ahhhha where am i going?
It makes me think of the scene in Little Miss Sunshine, where Steve Carrell's character tells the little girl about his suicide attempt. The father, Greg Kinnear, thinks it is insance. The mother, Toni Colette, thinks it is mature way of handling a reality. The question here and what I received from most of the 5 star reviews (?) is that it maturely handles a situation of unnaturally transformative medical procedures performed on their mother.
I think on the outlook this book appears more harmful than good, but moving past the shady writing of the manufacturer, this book has a demographic and it is not always for beauty reasons. And I think if a mother has to have plastic surgery done for whatever reason, a child should be informed that this is not natural.
It happened. It is in front of their eyes one day after it was not present before. Kids need to know that things are not so quick in a sense. Change minus a surgeon's knife takes a longer time.
I mean we can make an argument of an audit/real self here. If the parent does not inform the child of procedures they are unaware of, they will assume the false reality of what they see as real and not audited.
But I know the idea of selling a world of accepted plastic surgery to kids can seem scary. It appears that it is saying plastic surgery is alright. But we know it is an explanation.
Should we leave our kids blind to reality? If a parent has received plastic surgery how likely is a child to follow suit once they are older to make these decisions? I do not know, but sorry for the lack of cohesion--really interesting find!
It is extremely sad that our society has found a need for a book like this. This only teaches children from a young age that they must have the perfect body, and if they don't have that body, then surgery is obviously the only way to fix it. This is a horrible lesson to be teaching children. Although I understand that sometimes plastic surgery is necessary and a book like this might be a good way to explain a potentially traumatic situation for a child, I am worried that those mothers that get plastic surgery for merely cosmetic reason could use a book like this to give them impression that changing your body like this is ok.
ReplyDelete